Here's a summary of the United States Supreme Court's decision in Barnes v. Felix (2025). You can read the opinion by clicking here.
Roberto Felix, a law enforcement officer, pulled over Ashtian Barnes for suspected toll violations. When Barnes tried to drive away, Felix jumped onto the car’s doorsill and fired two shots inside, fatally wounding Barnes. Barnes’s mother sued Felix, claiming excessive force violating the Fourth Amendment.
The lower courts applied a "moment-of-threat" rule, looking only at the very brief moment right before the shooting (two seconds when Felix was on the doorsill) to decide if the force was reasonable. They found Felix’s actions lawful because he could have reasonably felt his life was in danger at that moment.
The Supreme Court unanimously rejected that narrow focus. Instead, it ruled that determining if police used excessive force requires looking at the totality of the circumstances — including the events leading up to the shooting, not just the final seconds. This means the courts must consider the entire context of the encounter, not just the immediate moment of the use of force.
The Court vacated the lower court’s ruling and sent the case back for reconsideration with this broader perspective.
Justice Kavanaugh concurred, emphasizing the inherent dangers of traffic stops for officers, especially when a driver flees. He noted the difficult split-second decisions officers must make in such high-risk situations and stressed courts must balance the officer’s safety concerns with constitutional rights without hindsight bias.
In short, the ruling pushes back against overly narrow legal standards that ignore context leading up to police shootings, demanding a fuller, fact-rich look at what happened before and during the use of force. It doesn't excuse excessive force but insists courts consider the whole story.
Girards Law Firm specializes in severe injury and wrongful death cases, especially those that involve brain damage, heart damage, spinal cord injuries or severe burns in Texas, Arkansas and Oklahoma. Contact us at www.girardslaw.com by using the chat feature for more information.